MOSCOW, January 19, 2006 – There are indications that a failed civil court
case brought by a gay postgraduate and Lomonosov Moscow State University
has reached the office of Russian President Vladimir Putin.
The
postgraduate, Nikolai Alekseev, who head the GayRussia.ru project in Moscow
and is also executive secretary of the International Day Against Homophobia,
claimed discrimination of grounds of sexual orientation by the university
and sought “material and moral compensation” when he was denied the subject
‘The Legal Status of Sexual Minorities” for a scientific thesis.
In June
last year, the Nikulinsky local court in Moscow found against Mr. Alekseev,
after several hours of consideration. The judge said that she could not
find “anything that contradicts the law” in the actions of the university.
Mr.
Alekseev had also claimed that information about his sexuality had been made
public within the faculty, while the university insisted that it was Mr.
Alekseev himself who was “the distributor of the information on his own
homosexuality.
In
September last year, three judges at Moscow City Court dismissed an appeal
by Mr. Alekseev, saying that the lower court decision was correct, even
though Mr. Alekseev claimed there were mistakes in the original ruling.
Yesterday, it came to light that a French citizen had written to President
Putin regarding this case last June, immediately following the lower court
decision.
The
letter, from ‘Joel L’ asked the President to “provide for fair consideration
of the appeal”. He pointed out to the President there had been an unfair
judgement by the lower court as discrimination on grounds of sexual
orientation had been proven.
‘Joel L’
also said that if the Moscow City Court also found for the University, Mr.
Alekseev would then be entitled to petition the European Court of Human
Rights in Strasbourg.
It has
now come to light that the Russian President’s office reacted immediately to
this letter and forwarded it to the Moscow City Court, with an annotation to
the part of the letter that said: “N. Alekseev was sacked from the
postgraduate programme of MSU for his non traditional sexual orientation. On
10th June 2005 Nikulinsky local court of Moscow under the pressure from MSU
dismissed the claims of N. Alekseev”
Court
records show that when the deputy head of the Moscow City Court, Mr. A.V.
Paukov, received the letter from the Russian President’s office he
immediately forwarded it Mrs. T.A. Verzilina, the head of the lower court,
asking that the letter be filed in the case records before being sent to the
higher court for the appeal hearing.
It is
not clear as to whether or not the three appeal judges – one man and two
women – ever saw the letter and the interest in the case being shown by the
President’s office.
“I am
glad that Administration of Russian President showed their interest in this
case and immediately reacted to the letter in my support,” Mr. Alekseev said
last night. “This hopefully means that the Russian President, as a
guarantor of the constitution and the rights provided in it, is taking all
the steps to restore justice.”
He added
that his complaint to the European Court of Human Rights against Russian
Federation is being drawn by Austrian and British lawyers.
“But it
could well be that the case will be decided in Russia before the start of
the Strasbourg hearing. There is a strong possibility that the results of
the process will be reconsidered,” he added.