The comprehensive resource for vacations and hotels marketed to the LGBT community










 Military Surveillance of Gay Student Groups Recalls McCarthy Era Crackdowns



Historians React to Secret Pentagon Database



SANTA BARBARA, December 19, 2005  –  The recent revelation that the U.S. military is spying on gay rights groups, say historians, evokes the Cold War crackdowns on gays during the McCarthy era, academics say.

Then, as now, the government compiled lists of American citizens who were suspected of subversive activity by virtue of their association with critics of government policy.  Targets included gays and members of gay or gay-friendly groups.

Last week, NBC News reported it had obtained sections of a secret Pentagon database with information about individuals linked to peaceful activist and protest groups that opposed certain U.S. military actions.

According to the Advocate, the military has been monitoring meetings and events it deems “suspicious,” including gatherings of several student groups at the University of California, New York University and William Patterson College.  Students were meeting to discuss and oppose the military’s policy excluding openly gay Americans from serving in uniform.  At least one protest was classified as “possibly violent.”

A spokesman for the Defense Department said the Pentagon has “a legitimate interest” in using personal information about private citizens to “protect its installations and people.”

But according to David K. Johnson, a historian at University of South Florida and author of The Lavender Scare: The Cold War Persecution of Gays and Lesbians in the Federal Government, the banner of “national security” has long been used as a pretext to crack down on gay rights and even to spark moral crusades against homosexuality under the guise of national defense.

His book explains that “security risk” was used throughout the Cold War to invoke “the specter of homosexuality,” which was cast as a threat to national security, and as something that “needed to be systematically removed” from the government and minimized in the culture at large.

As far as is known, the current surveillance does not target homosexuality itself, but rather gay groups which have voiced opposition to the “don't ask, don't tell” policy barring openly gay service.

But as described in Johnson’s book, the historical pattern for thwarting gay freedom has been “guilt by association.”

Joseph McCarthy singled out Americans who read Communist literature, and took aim at gays because they “had extremely close connections with other individuals with the same tendencies.”  The McCarthy era was also known for keeping lists of individuals deemed “security risks” because they had a history of alcoholism, Liberalism, disloyalty and even “loquaciousness.”

Dr. Johnson said the Pentagon’s spying is the latest in a long history of targeting gays and lesbians as subversives, despite lacking any evidence for such a charge.

“It's no surprise,” he said.  “The federal government began spying on those who challenged its discriminatory policies from the very earliest days of such activism.”

He said the FBI investigated the first organizational meeting in 1961 of what became the Mattachine Society, one of the earliest gay rights groups.  Government agents took photographs in 1965 at the first gay and lesbian public demonstration in front of the White House against the military’s exclusionary policies.

“What is surprising,” he continued, “is that in nearly a half century of undercover intelligence gathering, they haven’t yet figured out that these are always peaceful, lawful protests.”

Nathaniel Frank, a historian and Senior Research Fellow at the Center for the Study of Sexual Minorities in the Military, a research institute at the University of California, Santa Barbara, said there have been important advances made in the rights of gays and lesbians since the McCarthy era.

“The witch hunts in the military have diminished,” he said, referring to the process of identifying gay and lesbian service members through invasive and degrading methods.

“We don't see the ‘queer stockades’, the deliberate humiliation and sanctioned physical abuse that used to characterized military life for gays who served their country."

But he expressed concern that what the Pentagon defends as routine security measures has too often been used to vilify, thwart or even harm gay people.

“While tolerance and treatment of gay Americans has generally improved since the Cold War,” said Dr. Frank, “both our government and the popular imagination have frequently used ‘national security’ to run roughshod over the rights of gay patriots.

The line between legitimate defence needs and abuse or exploitation of minorities in this country is easily blurred.  What needs to be vigilantly monitored right now is not peaceful gay groups but our national commitment to keeping this line in sharp focus.

■  The Lavender Scare: The Cold War Persecution of Gays and Lesbians in the Federal Government by David K. Johnson is published by University Of Chicago Press (January 1, 2004).  ISBN: 0226404811; 312pp; list price $30 (Amazon USA price is $19.80 – Amazon UK £15.51


Center for the Study of Sexual Minorities in the Military website.  The Center is governed by a distinguished board of advisors including the Honorable Lawrence J. Korb of the Center for American Progress, Honorable Coit Blacker of Stanford University and Professor Janet Halley of Harvard Law School. Its mission is to promote the study of gays, lesbians, and other sexual minorities in the armed forces



Recent Articles
(go to Archive main page
 for full archive search)

December 19: USA: 
I’m Afraid for His Life, Gay Soldier’s Mom Says.  The mother of a gay American teenage soldier has told a newspaper that she is afraid for his life, following a homophobic assault, allegedly by another soldier, in Arizona. 
“I have been crying myself to sleep,” Sheila Lawson told the Arizona Daily Star which revealed the case of 19 years-old Private Kyle Lawson.

December 18:
Gay Rainbow Flags In Moscow’s Famous Lubyanka SquareTwenty years ago it would have been an absurd dream: a thousand protesting activists on the streets of Moscow and then congregating in Lubyanka Square, which is dominated by the building that once held the KGB.

Latvia Latvian Gays Seek International Support for Petition to President.  Gay and lesbian activists have launched an online petition calling on the Latvian president not to sign the constitutional amendment that would define marriage as being between a man and a woman.

December 16:
Polish Gays Take Warsaw to European Court of Human Rights - Mayor, Now Polish President-elect, Cited.  A claim that the “President of the Capital city of Warsaw” breached the European Convention on Human Rights was lodged today at the European Court of Human Rights by the organisers of the Warsaw Equality Parade, often dubbed “Pride Parade”.

Russia Moscow To Stage Mr. Gay Russia at Pride.   A competition to find Mr. Gay Russia is the latest event to be announced for the first-ever Moscow Gay Pride Festival, due to be staged at the end on May next year.

Czech Republic Registered Partnership for Czech Gays On Its Way to Senate. The Chamber of Deputies – the Lower House of the Parliament of the Czech Republic – passed the Bill for registered partnership of same-sex couples by an 86-54 margin today.

UK Victim of Brutal Homophobic Assault Urges Gays To Report Incidents As His Attackers Are JailedThe victim of a horrific homophobic assault in Northern Ireland today called for all victims of homophobia to make their voices heard.  Terry McCartney was speaking as Steven Devenny (21) of Rinmore Drive, Creggan, was sentenced to three years in jail and co-accused Ciaran Rodgers (18), of Little Diamond in the Bogside, was given a year in jail and a year on probation for the attack.

December 15:
Gay TV Personality Criticises Latvian Parliament As Euro-MPs Have Their Say.  From an “out gay” television personality in Latvia to Members of the European Parliament, there has been continued criticism of Latvia's Saeima (Parliament)

Gay Couple Loses Benefits of £6,000 a Year As Civil Partnerships Hit Poor, Sick and Elderly.  Andrew Brettell is 63 years old and lives in Kent with his 44 year-old partner Martin.  They have ‘cohabited’ for 18 years and took out a mortgage on their home 16 years ago, long before civil partnerships were considered possible – in the ‘bad old days’ when gay people had no legal rights.

Latvia Latvia Cements Homophobia Into Constitution As Gay Marriage is Banned.  The Latvia Parliament has adopted a constitutional change that defines marriage as a union of a man and a woman.  This will prevent any possibility for gay marriage in the future.  This morning, 65 MPs voted in favour of the change at the amendment’s third – and final – reading in Parliament.

December 14:
SLDN Saves Three Dozen Military Careers in 2005 from Discharge Under ‘Don’t Ask, Don't Tell’.  Servicemembers Legal Defense Network (SLDN) has intervened to save the military careers in 2005 of three dozen gay service men and women, it was announced today.

Asian Gays and Lesbians Celebrate 10 Years of Online Utopia Websites seem to have a shorter shelf life than a ripe banana, but one pioneering Internet portal is celebrating a decade of service providing a free, safe and popular online community for millions of homosexuals in Asia.

Poland Court Declares Illegality of Poznań Mayor’s Decision to Ban Polish Gay March.  The ‘voivodeship’ administrative court in Poznan has ruled that the ban of the Equality March in November by Ryszard Grobelny, the mayor of Poznań, was illegal under the Polish and European laws.

December 12:
US Gay Groups Oppose Nomination of Samuel Alito to Supreme CourtFour of the leading gay and lesbian advocacy organizations in the United States have today announced their opposition to the nomination of Samuel A. Alito to the Supreme Court of the United States.

December 9:
International Human Rights Day: How Much Is There To Celebrate for  Gays in Europe? Tomorrow is International Human Rights Day when the world is marking the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948.


Posted: 19 December 2005 at 23:00 (UK time)